Key Takeaways
- A parent can nominate a guardian by Will or other signed writing, and the court may appoint that person if both parents are dead and the nominee is eligible and serves the child's best interests (SDCL 29A-5-202).
- A child 14 or older can nominate a guardian, and that nomination comes before a parent's.
- Every nominee must file a criminal history check and a civil judgment check with the court at least ten days before the hearing, and complete state-required training.
- A guardian and a conservator can be different people.
What happens to your children if you die without naming a guardian in South Dakota?
If both parents die without naming a guardian, a South Dakota circuit court judge chooses who raises your children, usually after relatives file competing petitions. South Dakota gives no relative an automatic right to the job. Grandparents, aunts, uncles and family friends can all ask, and the judge decides based on the child's best interests.
The petition can come from the minor, an interested relative, the person who has taken responsibility for the child's care, the person the minor has nominated, or any other interested person (SDCL 29A-5-203). The court sets a hearing within 60 days, and the notice and petition are personally served on the minor if the minor is 10 or older (29A-5-204).
The statute lists what the court weighs when no one has nominated anyone: the proposed guardian's geographic location, relationship to the minor, ability to carry out the job, commitment to the child's welfare, any conflicts of interest, the recommendations of the parents or other interested relatives, and the wishes of the minor if the minor is old enough to form an intelligent preference (29A-5-202).
If you have named someone, you shortcut much of this. Read our South Dakota estate planning guide for the other documents that go with a Will.
Who can be a guardian in South Dakota?
South Dakota's statute is detailed. Any adult individual may be appointed guardian if capable of providing an active and suitable program of guardianship for the minor, and if not employed by an agency or facility that provides substantial services or financial assistance to the minor. The court can waive the employment rule if the appointment is in the minor's best interest (SDCL 29A-5-110).
Other rules:
- Someone whose only interest is as a creditor of the minor is not eligible.
- A person convicted of a felony is not eligible unless the court finds the appointment is in the minor's best interests, after considering the offense, its date and evidence of rehabilitation.
- A nominee must get an Interstate Identification Index criminal history check and a check of South Dakota civil judgments for abuse, neglect or exploitation of an elder or adult with a disability, and file the results with the court at least ten days before the hearing. The court can waive or modify this for good cause.
- The judge cannot sign the order until the record checks are filed and reviewed and a certificate of completion of the required State Bar training has been filed (29A-5-110).
Your nominee will need to do these steps, so tell the person early. See common Will mistakes in South Dakota for what goes wrong when a named guardian cannot serve.
How the South Dakota court chooses
South Dakota sets the order in SDCL 29A-5-202:
- The minor, if 14 or older. A minor age 14 or older may nominate any individual or entity as guardian, in writing or by an oral request to the court. The court may appoint the nominee if the nominee is otherwise eligible and would serve in the minor's best interests.
- A deceased parent. Absent an effective nomination by the minor, the court may appoint a parental nominee if both parents are dead and the nominee is otherwise eligible and would serve in the minor's best interests. If both parents made nominations, the court selects the one it believes best qualified.
- The court's own choice. Absent either nomination, the court appoints the individual who will act in the minor's best interests, using the factors in the statute.
Two points stand out. A teenager's nomination outranks a parent's here, so talk to your children. And the word is "may," not "must." The court has discretion, and the determination of whether to appoint anyone is for the court alone, and only if it is in the minor's best interests (29A-5-208).
How much weight your choice in a Will carries
South Dakota gives your nomination real weight, in writing, but not control.
A parent of an unmarried minor may nominate a guardian by will or other signed writing. The nomination is effective whether or not the minor was living when you made it. So a Will written before your youngest child was born still counts. No parental nomination may supersede a previous appointment by the court (29A-5-202).
The court may appoint your nominee if both parents are dead, the nominee is eligible and the appointment serves the child's best interests. The statute does not say the court must appoint your pick.
What can stand in the way:
- A 14-year-old's own nomination. An effective nomination by the minor comes first.
- Eligibility. The record checks, training and the bar on certain felons and employees apply to your nominee.
- The court's determination. The court alone decides, based on the minor's best interests (29A-5-208).
If you and the other parent both nominate someone, the court picks the one it believes best qualified, so agree on one name.
A South Dakota Will must be in writing, signed by you, and signed by at least two witnesses who watched you sign or heard you acknowledge your signature. You must be 18 or older. A notarized self-proving affidavit lets the Will go through probate without the witnesses having to testify.
Guardian of the person vs managing the money
South Dakota separates the two jobs. The court appoints a guardian, a conservator or both for a minor, and it "need not appoint the same individual or entity to serve as both" (SDCL 29A-5-202). A conservator manages money.
A conservator is not automatic. When the court decides whether to appoint one, it considers among other things the extent to which the minor has money or other property requiring management or protection, and the availability of less restrictive alternatives (29A-5-208). A bank or trust company authorized to exercise trust powers in the state may be appointed conservator (29A-5-110).
So you can name a caring relative to raise your children, and a different person or a trust company to look after money. For larger inheritances, a trust lets you name a trustee and set the ages at which your children receive money. Read how to make a living trust in South Dakota.
For how a guardian and a Will fit together, see the relationship between legal guardianship and a Will.
How to choose the right guardian
The law sets the minimum. The real work is picking a person who will do the job well.
Would they say yes? Ask before you write the name down. Naming someone who has never been asked is the most common way a plan falls apart.
Do they share your values? Think about money, school, faith, discipline and health care. This person will make those calls for your children.
Can they take on kids right now? Consider their age, health, work, own children and home. A sibling across the country may mean your children change schools and lose their friends too.
Will your children stay together? Most parents want siblings raised in one home. Say so in your Will.
Who is your backup? Your first choice may die, move, get sick or change their mind. Name a second person, and a third if you can. Because the nominee has to complete record checks and training before the judge signs the order, a backup keeps your plan moving if the first person is delayed.
Should one person handle the money? Raising children and managing an inheritance are different jobs. Some parents pick one person for both. Others pick a caring relative for the first and a financially steady person for the second.
Review the choice after a birth, a move, a divorce or a death. Every plan includes unlimited edits, so changing a name takes minutes.
How to name a guardian with FastWill
El FastWill Will Package includes guardian naming. It is $199 for one person and $249 for a couple, and most people finish in about 30 minutes. Here is how the guardian part works.
- Start your Will. Answer the questions about you and your family. List your children by name.
- Name your guardian. Enter the person you want to raise your children. In South Dakota this is a nomination in your Will, and you can name a different person to manage your children's money.
- Name a backup. Add a second person who steps in if your first choice cannot or will not serve.
- Decide who manages the money. Choose who looks after anything your children inherit, and until what age. If you have a larger estate, think about whether a trust makes more sense. See how to make a living trust in South Dakota.
- Sign it correctly. A South Dakota Will must be in writing, signed by you, and signed by at least two witnesses who watched you sign or heard you acknowledge your signature. You must be 18 or older. South Dakota law lets your witnesses join by live video, so they do not have to be in the room, as long as everyone can see and hear each other in real time. A guardian named in a Will that was not signed properly may carry no weight at all.
- Store the original and tell people. Keep the signed original somewhere safe, and tell your executor and your chosen guardian where it is.
Every plan includes unlimited edits, so you can update your guardian later without starting over. For the full signing and witness steps, read how to make a Will in South Dakota.
Preguntas frecuentes
Does a South Dakota court have to appoint the guardian in my Will?
No. The court may appoint a parental nominee if both parents are dead, the nominee is eligible and the appointment serves the child's best interests (SDCL 29A-5-202). A nomination by a child 14 or older comes first.
Can my 14-year-old choose a different guardian?
A minor 14 or older may nominate a guardian in writing or by an oral request to the court. The court may appoint that person if they are eligible and it is in the child's best interests.
Can a family member with a felony be my guardian?
Only if the court finds the appointment is in the child's best interests, after considering the offense, how long ago it was and evidence of rehabilitation (29A-5-110).
Does my guardian need a background check?
Yes. A nominee, other than a bank or trust company, files a criminal history check and a civil judgment check at least ten days before the hearing, unless the court waives it for good cause (29A-5-110).
Does the nomination work if I wrote my Will before my last child was born?
Yes. A parental nomination is effective whether or not the minor was living when the will or signed writing was made (29A-5-202).
Sources
- SDCL 29A-5-110, qualifications for guardian or conservator
- SDCL 29A-5-201, appointment of guardian or conservator of minor
- SDCL 29A-5-202, nomination by minor or parent
- SDCL 29A-5-203, who may file petition
- SDCL 29A-5-204, notice of appointment hearing
- SDCL 29A-5-208, hearing and determination of appointment
This article is general information, not legal advice.