Key Takeaways
- Name a guardian in your Will, and name a backup.
- A guardian named in a Will can act only after the Will is probated and the court issues letters (SCPA 1710).
- New York has no fixed order of relatives. The judge picks whoever will serve the child's interests.
- If your child is over 14, the court must ask which guardian the child prefers (SCPA 1706).
What happens to your children if you die without naming a guardian in New York?
If both parents die and no guardian has been named, a New York court decides who raises your children. That is usually the Surrogate's Court, and it starts when someone files a petition. Under SCPA 1704, the petition has to tell the court who the child is, who the child lives with, and who the nearest adult relatives are if both parents have died. It also has to say whether a guardian was ever named for the child in a Will or deed, and what property the child has.
That means people outside your plan, even well meaning ones, are the ones putting names in front of a judge. Relatives can disagree. Someone can petition who you would never have chosen. A child over 14 can even petition for themselves (SCPA 1703).
None of that is a crisis if you have named someone. It is a real cost if you have not. Read what happens if you die without a Will in New York for the rest of what happens when there is no Will.
Who can be a guardian in New York?
The sections that govern the appointment (SCPA 1706 and 1707) work through a set of checks the court runs on the person who wants the job, rather than a list of qualifications.
- The court can appoint someone other than the parent or the person who filed. SCPA 1707 lets the judge pick a person other than the one the petitioner proposed, so naming someone does not box the court in.
- Child abuse records. The court must check whether the proposed guardian, or any adult living in the proposed guardian's home, appears in the state's central register of child abuse and maltreatment (SCPA 1706). If a nominee or an adult aged 18 or older in the home was the subject of an indicated report, or was found in a Family Court case to have abused or neglected a child, the court has to obtain those records and consider them (SCPA 1707).
- Security. When the guardian will handle the child's property, the court looks at whether the guardian's security is adequate (SCPA 1706).
Practically, choose an adult with a clean record, a stable home and no one in that home who would raise a flag.
How the New York court chooses
New York does not rank relatives. There is no rule that grandparents come before aunts or that siblings come before friends. The court appoints the person it finds will serve the child's interests (SCPA 1707).
Two age rules matter. If the child is over 14, the court must ask which guardian the child prefers (SCPA 1706). That is a duty to ask, not a rule that the child gets to choose. And if the young person is over 18, they must consent to the appointment. A guardian's term generally ends when the child reaches majority, and it can run to age 21 only if the young person agrees after turning 18 (SCPA 1707).
How much weight your choice in a Will carries
New York law lets a parent appoint a guardian by Will. SCPA 1710 applies to a parent who lived in New York when they died, and it says a Will-appointed guardian cannot act over the child's person or property until the Will is probated, recorded in the proper court, and letters of guardianship are issued.
Two things follow. First, the Will has to be found and filed, so tell your guardian where the original is kept. Second, the statute describes how the appointment becomes effective. It does not say how a court weighs your choice against a challenge, and this article does not say a court must follow your nomination. What a named guardian gives your family is a clear, written, signed choice from you, on file with the court, in place of a contested petition from strangers.
Guardian of the person vs. managing the money
Raising your child and managing your child's money are two jobs. SCPA 1707 lets the court appoint one person for both or two different people, one for the child's person and one for the child's property.
A guardian of the property handles money and assets the child owns, and the court looks at security for that role. The appointment generally ends when your child reaches majority. That is a reason many parents do not want their children to get everything outright at 18. If you want the money held and released on your timetable, a Trust can do that, and our guide to how to make a living Trust in New York covers it. A custodial account for a minor is another option, which a lawyer or your financial institution can set up.
How to choose the right guardian
The law decides who is allowed to serve. You decide who should. Write a short list and test each name against the questions below. For the fuller picture of how a guardian and a Will fit together, read how legal guardianship and a Will work together.
Values and parenting. Pick someone whose way of raising kids you would trust on a bad day, not only a good one. Religion, discipline, school choices and how they handle money around children all matter. You do not need a perfect match. You need no big surprises.
Stability and health. Think about age, health, work hours and their own household. A grandparent may be the person your kids love most and still be a hard fit if they are in their seventies. Be honest about energy and about how long the person can realistically serve.
Where they live. A guardian who lives across the country means your children may also lose their school, friends and home on top of losing you. If you pick someone far away, make that choice on purpose.
Their willingness. Ask before you write the name down. Some people say yes out of guilt. Give them room to say no, and tell them what the role involves.
Your kids' relationship with them. Children who already know and trust the person will cope better. If you have more than one child, think about whether the guardian can take all of them, because keeping siblings together usually matters.
Money. A great caregiver is not always a great money manager. Raising the children and managing what you leave them are separate jobs, and in some cases it makes sense to give them to two different people or to put the money in a Trust. Our guide to how to make a living Trust in New York explains that option.
Fairness within the family. If your choice may hurt feelings, such as picking your sister over your parents, tell people before it matters. A guardian who has been told in advance and who has already said yes is less likely to face a fight.
Last, name a backup. People move, get sick, divorce and change their minds. A backup guardian keeps your plan working when the first choice cannot serve.
How to name a guardian with FastWill
Naming a guardian is one part of your Will, and it is built into the FastWill Will Package. You enter your children, choose a guardian for them and choose a backup guardian. Most people finish the whole Will in about 30 minutes.
Here is how it works.
- Start with your children. List each child, including any you expect to have.
- Pick your guardian and a backup. Use the questions above. Enter the full legal names of both.
- Decide who handles the money. If you want a different person, or a Trust, to manage what your children inherit, set that up in the same sitting.
- Sign your Will correctly. A guardian named in a Will that was not signed and witnessed properly may not hold up. Our guide to how to make a Will in New York walks through the steps.
- Tell your guardian. Give them a copy and tell them where the original is kept.
The Will Package is $199 for one person and $249 for a couple. Every plan includes unlimited edits, so if your pick changes, you can update the Will and sign the new version. If you want a Trust to hold your children's money, the Trust Package is $499 for one person and $599 for a couple.
If you are not sure what the court does when no one is named, see what happens if you die without a Will in New York. For the bigger picture, see our New York estate planning guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I name a guardian for my children in a New York Will?
Yes. SCPA 1710 applies to a parent who lived in New York at death and who appointed a guardian by Will. The guardian cannot act until the Will is probated and the court issues letters.
Does my guardian take over right away?
No. Under SCPA 1710, the guardian cannot act until the Will has been probated and recorded and letters of guardianship have been issued. Until then, your family may need the court's help, so keep your Will where your executor and guardian can find it.
Does my child get a say in who raises them?
If your child is over 14, the court must ask which guardian they prefer (SCPA 1706). The child's preference is considered, but the statute does not say it controls. Over 18, the young person must consent to the appointment.
Can I pick one person to raise my kids and another to manage their money?
Yes, in the sense that SCPA 1707 lets a court appoint one individual for both roles or different individuals for the child's person and property. You can say who you want for each role in your Will, and a Trust is another way to handle the money.
I have a spouse. Do I still need to name a guardian?
Yes. The question only comes up if both parents are gone, but that is exactly the case a named guardian is for. A guardian and a backup cost you a few minutes and give your family a written answer.
Sources
- New York SCPA 1703, who may petition for a guardian of an infant
- New York SCPA 1704, contents of the petition
- New York SCPA 1706, hearing, child's preference and security
- New York SCPA 1707, appointment of a guardian
- New York SCPA 1710, guardians appointed by will or deed
This article is general information, not legal advice.